Force Recon Vs Seals - When there's an iconic image floating around of a special operator with a bushy beard and a well-used rifle standing in an unspecified distant country, there's a good chance it's US Army Special Forces (SF sometimes known as Green Berets). These men are tough to the bone, and while they are capable of direct action attacks, their primary mission is to train foreigners. The SF's classic mission would be to insert itself into a hostile country, train a local group whose interests are aligned with the United States, and then fight alongside them. That takes years of training and retraining, from learning languages to making explosives and everything in between.
United States Marine Corps Forces Special Operations Command (MARSOC) is the Marine Corps' contribution to today's special operations on the battlefield. Also known as Marine Raiders, they are capable of performing complex direct-action attacks and high-level reconnaissance. Raiders are not the same as Marine Force Recon: although Force Recon is an elite unit, it does not belong to Special Operations Command (SOCOM) like MARSOC. MARSOC is the latest addition to the major special operations groups, having been activated in 2006.
Force Recon Vs Seals
Green Berets assigned to the 3rd Special Group (Airborne) prepare for an exfiltration on August 15, 2019, near Hurlburt Field, Florida. Photo by Sp. Peter Seidler/US Army.
Marine Raiders Vs. Special Forces: Here's What You Need To Know
Despite the legendary status of each component of Special Ops, each is constantly competing for relevance. Today's battlefield never stops evolving, and these so-called "special" groups wouldn't be special if they didn't evolve with it.
Coffee or Die spoke with Colonel Neil Schuehle (retired), a Navy officer who sat at the table from 2002 to 2005, when the groundwork was being laid for a Navy component in SOCOM. Schuehle also served as the first commanding officer of the Navy's West Coast Special Operations Battalion. It shed light on some similarities and differences between MARSOC and Army Special Forces.
One set of core missions that many groups are tasked with is FID (Foreign Internal Defense). This is the core mission of SF - training foreign defense - but it has permeated all levels of SOF, including MARSOC. Even units whose sole purpose is to hit targets hard in the middle of the night will at some point find themselves training foreign military and/or militants. As the climate of war continues to change, the nuances of warfare become more complex. Large direct action raids by US forces may not be a realistic option, even by covert SOF groups, when friendly forces can be trained across the border to accomplish the same mission. War is a game of chess, and sometimes the boldest move isn't the smartest.
U.S. Marines with Navy Special Operations Command conduct a strike in support of a UH-1 battle exercise during Weapons and Tactics Instructor Course (WTI) 2-19 at Yuma Proving Ground, Arizona, April 5, 2019. Photo by Cpl. Sabrina Candiaflores/United States Marine Corps.
Usmc 26th Meu 1st Force Recon
MARSOC was also established with the FID as its main focus. They're not just casually training foreigners when asked to do so overseas, "they've adopted their FID card and definitely put a Marine Corps stamp on it," Schuehle said. Special Forces have Robin Sage as their crowning training exercise; MARSOC has the Derna Bridge. Like SF, MARSOC operators must also learn a foreign language; however, like their SF counterparts, some move on to advanced training, while others remain at a more basic level.
Another similarity between the SF and MARSOC is that, in addition to combat deployments, they tend to deploy to countries around the world allied with the United States. The deployment could be close to a conflict area or it could just be a friendly training deployment between two nations sharing knowledge of some of their most valuable tactical assets. This is in contrast to a group like the US Army Rangers, which generally only deploy in areas of severe conflict.
It is unlikely that 30 special forces operators would descend into a valley to train a few locals; more than likely, you'll have about a dozen men, all highly trained and determined to keep a low subscription. MARSOC also operates in small teams, but they train to a level where they can conduct full-scale infantry-type operations: a full 100-man assault is not out of the question for MARSOC, nor is it outside their training regimen.
A Marine from the US Marine Corps Forces, Special Operations Command provides security at a landing zone in Nahr-e Saraj district, Helmand province, March 28, 2012. Photo by Cpl. Kyle McNally/United States Marine Corps/Freed.
Recon Marines Train For New Roles
"We include CQB (proximity battle) in our basic course, while for SEAL and SF, these are later advanced courses," Schuehle said. "It creates a core element that unfolds with a more Ranger-like DA (direct action) capability, but that said, the emphasis certainly remains on the FID."
As with all SOF groups, cultural rivalries abound. MARSOC is seen by some as a child of SOCOM, struggling to find its niche and maintain relevance as many jobs are covered by other groups. And if MARSOC is the kid, Special Forces can be seen as the great-grandfather. They are also struggling to find relevance, as FID work goes to conventional forces and DA missions go to special mission units like Delta Force and Rangers (the former has more DA training; the latter has more firepower per man, mainly with a larger arsenal of crew weapons with maintenance).
The reality is that Special Operator jobs are constantly changing, which means that the jobs of all SOF groups are too. What makes these groups - and the men who comprise them - so special isn't that they know how to shoot and conduct complex tactical raids (although that certainly plays a part). Its main advantage is its flexibility. MARSOC and SF will remain relevant as long as they demonstrate that they can do what is required of them, whether that be training foreigners, packing a heavy punch in a directional action attack deep behind enemy lines, or something else entirely.
Luke Ryan is an associate editor at Coffee or Die Magazine and the author of two books of war poetry: "The Gun and the Scythe" and "A Moment of Violence". Luke grew up abroad in Pakistan and Thailand, the son of aid workers. He later served as an Army Ranger and led four detachments into Afghanistan, leaving him as a team leader. He has published over 600 written works on a variety of platforms, including the New York Times.
Dam 78056 Marine Force Recon Combat Diver (desert Marpat Version)
The American author so closely associated with the soldier's ethic may not have served in the military, but that didn't stop him from winning medals in both world wars.
After the United States approved the transfer of armored Bradleys in early January, European nations are close to sending main battle tanks to Ukraine.
A team of nine veterans concluded their skydiving expedition with one last celebratory jump in Florida on Wednesday, January 18th.
Killed just a week before D-Day, the body of 1st Lt. Melvin B. Meyer, a B-17 bomber in Europe, was identified in September 2022.
Navy Seals Vs. Marines: 4 Major Differences Between The 2
Russia's Federal Security Service said on Thursday it had opened a spying case against a US citizen, but did not name the person or specify whether he was in custody.
The US Coast Guard's 14th District headquarters in Honolulu is responsible for the Hawaiian Islands and much of the Pacific stretching all the way to Japan, and they recently tracked a Russian vessel nearly 8,000 miles from their home.
When Major Shawn Campbell was killed in a helicopter crash, his wife, Kelli, struggled to find a school for their four young children. Folds of Honor, a non-profit focused on veterans, helped them find the right school in a new city.
Hollywood got a lot wrong about the Marine Corps' deadliest battle, but not everything. Here's what they got right. Marines with the 3rd Reconnaissance Battalion, 3rd Marine Division and US Marines Airmen of the 320th Special Tactics Squadron participate in a Marine Corps Combat Readiness Assessment at Camp Schwab, Okinawa, Japan, in November 17, 2020. (Photo by Lance Cpl. Alexis Moradian, Marine Corps)
Task Force Violent: The Unforgiven
In the not-too-distant future, on a dark night in the middle of the South Pacific, a small Marine recon team, accompanied by a handful of Special Forces airmen, dives from 10,000 feet onto a small enemy-controlled atoll.
Marines focus their fire on the enemy, while Marine Corps Paratroopers and Air Force Guardian Angels quickly deal with any casualties on the battlefield. An Air Force combat controller calls in a swift airstrike, silencing the enemy as the US unit successfully captures the small atoll.
While Marines provide security, Combat Controllers quickly get to work making sure the island's level terrain is safe to land a C-130 carrying a single High Mobility Artillery Rocket System rocket launcher.
Within minutes, combat controllers land the C-130 and HIMARS pulls out from behind, ready to fire a barrage of rockets behind enemy lines.
Mp Realistic Seal Team 6 [call Of Duty 4: Modern Warfare] [mods]
The military concept is called
Navy seals vs force recon, marine recon vs seals, air force recon, force recon, usmc force recon, recon marines vs seals, seals vs force recon, browning recon force 4k, ear force recon 70p, force recon marines vs navy seals, browning recon force edge, seals vs recon
0 Comments